Monday, November 14, 2016

Historical and Rhetorical: The Black Panthers

Historical context: The Black Panthers
            The Civil Rights movement that took place during the mid 50’s in America, featured some of the most iconic protest in history. It also gave birth to some radical protest groups. One of those is ‘The Black Panthers’. A group that started with two men made with one goal in mind and that was to give not only African American, but every single person who was oppressed or part of the lower class equality. Equality in school, healthcare and overall living. They went about it in different ways, some violent and others not so violent, but they fought in ways they thought were necessary to gain their goals for equality.
            To start we must look at the beginning of the black panthers and what led to their creation. The group was founded in the mid 60’s by Huey P Newton and Bobby Seale after they met at Merritt College. Huey had received a month long prison term for knife assault just before meeting Seale. (Carpini 191) Newton and Seale formed the Black Panther Party during a time of war. The U.S. was in the middle of the Vietnam War and African American men were being drafted to go fight over for that war. The thinking was that why would they go fight overseas when there was a war to be won at home. (Nelson, Black Panthers Vanguard of the Revolution)
            The Black Panthers had put together a ten-point program which outlined all their wants to better their group and their people. To begin they wanted freedom, and full employment opportunities, as they felt like they weren’t able to get the same type of jobs white folk had. The Black Panthers wanted to bring an end to capitalism that they felt were robbing their communities. The Black Panthers also wanted, descent housing, an equal school system and free health care not just for black people, but for all of the oppressed. They wanted to end the police brutality that was happening throughout that city of Oakland and all across the country. One point they made was to have all conflicts around the world be stopped. And, finally, they wanted a fair justice and a chance to have an equal playing field with technology, food, healthcare and other items that the white folk had access to. (North American Review 16-17)
            While The Black Panther Party had a list of what they wanted to get accomplished, they also did things on their own. One of those things was healthcare. It’s something that people don’t really know and also something that most books never talk about. By 1965 the Black Panthers had 13 different health care clinics set up across the country. (Bassett, 741)  A couple of those places being Boston, Massachusetts and Mississippi. Not bad for a group started by two people in Oakland. The main message that the BPP wanted to get across by doing this is that healthcare is not a privilege but a right, something that people believe and still call back to today. (Bassett, 743)
            Continuing the talk about the healthcare that the BPP had set up, they also went after doctors who had graduated college and wanted to make people feel as though they were at a clinic that was better than most that the privileged folk had. The first clinic which was opened thanks to Ronald Satchel and Fred Hampton in Lawndale, Chicago were able to attract good doctors to the clinic. One doctor name Quentin Young did doctoring work at the Chicago clinic. He went there because of what he had seen in terms of how one-sided health care had been while he attended the University of Chicago. Young says that the whites had received health care at the school, while the blacks were sent away to whatever run down hospital would take them in. Young also says that the medical clinics were used as a tacrical and survival strategy. They served as a way for members of the BPP to stay out of the police line of sight and stay low. Young’s partnership left a long term positive association wit professional alumni. (Brown 756-757)
As the clinic was gaining exposure and people were happy with the job being done, authorities thought it was their duty to step in. They came in and tried to hand down different health violations, mostly fabricated, that would result in the shutdown of the clinic. The attempt would not work and the clinic still remains open to this day helping anywhere from twenty to thirty people on a daily basis according to a volunteer. Along with still being open, and helping people, a Black Panther advocate stays at the center and personally conducts interviews with almost every single patient. (Quentin Young, 754-755)
            Of course the Black Panther Party was more famous for their more radical and what some would call extremist measures. A section of the Black Panthers called themselves the Vanguard, and this most likely is where they got the more radical image from. Members of this vanguard would walk around with guns out, because at the time if you carried a gun you had to carry it out in the open. The only way that it would be a crime is if the person who had the gun was already a felon. They took their guns everywhere with them, so that if they spotted any police action going on they would stand at a far distance sweeping their guns back and forth, not aiming, but intimidating. Standing at a distance could ensure that police could not say they were a distraction, or interfering in an arrest. The Vanguard did this so that no police brutality could happen or would stop immediately if it was going on. (Nelson, Black Panthers Vanguard of the Revolution)
            The Black Panthers had no screening process for members, they needed people and were willing to bring in whoever and whenever. With a joining process so easy the Panthers would often get some more crazy members that would add on to this radical image. Enter Eldridge Cleaver, a man who was a literary writer and would always try his best to invoke craziness and violence. Over time, Eldridge would become a new face for the black Panthers.
            On October 27th, 1968 Huey Newton would fatally shoot an Oakland police officer. Eldridge with his newly found leadership held a press conference where he wanted Huey Netwon to be free. He went on to say that if the police did not free him then it would be very hard for the Oakland police to avoid an open armed war sweeping across the nation. Protests were then held for days on end with the tagline of “Free Huey!” Huey would be convicted and released in 1970, a short time thanks in part to the protests  that were being held almost daily for Huey.
            The Black Panthers were a hip group that changed the civil rights movement that was once started and gained traction by Martin Luther King Jr. People wanted to dress like them, they wanted to move like them. The Black Panthers helped shape a community and give a personality to those that were oppressed.
            In 1989, Huey Lewis would be shot and killed in Oakland Calidofrnia. Tyronne Robinson admitted to the killing of Huey. Police believe that Robinsons, who was a drug dealer, would not sell Newton drugs. After arguing for a few minutes Newton tried to steal the drugs leading to the fatal shooting.
           



Work Cited
1.     Bassett, Mary T. "Beyond Berets: The Black Panthers as Health Activists." American Journal of Public Health 106.10 (2016): 741-743. Web
2.     "The Black Panther Ten-Point Program." The North American Review 253.4 (1968): 16-17. Web.
3.     "Quentin Young on the Black Panther Party Free Clinic in Chicago." American Journal of Public Health 106.10 (2016): 754-755. Web.
4.     Brown, Theodore M. "Working With the Panthers to Transform Health Care for Poor Black Communities." American Journal of Public Health 106.10 (2016): 756-757. Web.
5.     http://www.youtube.com/channel/UCBTgeHX7jn0rjSViu7EE92A. "'The Black Panthers Vanguard Of The Revolution' Full Film Documentary 2015." YouTube. YouTube, 2016. Web. 11 Nov. 2016.

 Rhetorical Analysis
            We all know that Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. was all for non violent protests. We all remember his march on Washington, and the infamous “I Have A Dream Speech” but the Black Panthers were different. It’s important to explore how the Panthers differentiated themselves from MLK and how they preached violence, while also preaching peace. The only thing the Black Panthers ever actually wanted was equality. Equality through any means necessary.
            Some people, and writers, have their own views about what exactly the BPP were protesting and why. David Oppenheimer a writer for the University of California Press wrote about the Black Panthers. He wrote that the members are nothing more than a race of people who were proud of their identity. (Oppenheimer, University of California Press) This way of looking at the BPP protests is a new way, and one that I never saw until I started writing this paper. It is a new way of looking at the group, but it is also, maybe a misconception.
            The first part that I would like to talk about from that statement above, is what does he mean by their identity? Could he be talking about the the way the group has gained a face as a more extremeist and radical group? As stated in the historical context, the group gained that more radical look because they carried guns in the open and forced California and the country to change that law. To say that the BPP were only proud of that extremist identity, would almost have to be wrong. Because the BPP were not only about causing violence, they wanted to generally help those that were oppressed, and looked down upon, It’s also important to note that white men also took part in the “Free Huey” protest, so as we can see the BPP were not only a group of radicals.
You can also make the case that by saying that about the BPP, the writer is discrediting them of their impact on society. They brought a new wave of clothing, changed not only laws, but pop culture as a whole. People wanted to be a Black Panther. They wanted to dress the part and be the part. Bobby Seale and Huey Newton made the group to end the oppression and racism, but the lasting effects left a huge mark on our nation and for a group of people as a whole.
We can also see that in the way that protests have come around our country, one of the most recent being Colin Kaepernick and his protesting of the flag. He is spreading the message of the BPP by wearing shirts that feature the famous panther and spending time in more oppressed areas, to get a message out. Just recently he created a Black Panthers inspired youth camp. (Finlay, Huffington Post) Other stars such Beyonce have even brought the organization back into the spotlight with her recent performance in the Super Bowl halftime show. To sit and write that the Black Panther Party was only a group proud of their identity is kind of a harsh generalization.
After Beyonce had done her Super Bowl performance some analysts called the Black Panther Party militant thuggery and propaganda. One Milwaukee county sherrif even had this to say about it.  “Them coming out, Beyonce, in those Black Panther type uniforms, would that be acceptable if a white band came out in hoods and white sheets in the same sort of fashion? We would be appalled and outraged.” (2)
            As I was doing research I found another first thanks to that sherriff. I had never heard anyone compare the Black Panther Party to the Ku Klux Klan. Comparing those two groups together is kind of like comparing apples and oranges. Sure the Black Panthers were all about force and aggression, but they were not trying to harm anybody, or a single race of people for the sake of doing it. As ive said countless times throughout this paper, their sole mission as a group was to end the oppression, by any means necessary. MLK had the same goal, the only difference here was that he wanted to do it peacefully.
            Looking at what the KKK wanted to do, they wanted to keep on oppressing the black people that were in KKK territory. We all know thow they would go about doing those things is something we all know of, and we have all heard the story of Emmett Till so no further explanation is needed there, but the Similarities between the KKK and BPP only come across with the violence. While the Black Panthers wanted to have their guns out at all times and really instill fear and intimidate police and anybody who helped the oppressions, the KKK wanted to be violent at all times.
The KKK philosophy was to hurt or kill everyone who wasn’t white, or to hurt those that helped the blacks. The Black Panthers wanted everyone to help end the oppressions. White people would gather with the Panthers to help protest issues and voice concerns of their own. For an officer of the law to make that sort of comparison is outrageous in its own right. I’m sure he hasn’t been the first and most likely will not be the last but it is still a crazy comparison to begin with.
Another thing to talk about it the comments made by some analyst that I mentioned earlier. Calling the Black Panthers ‘militant thugs’ and ‘propaganda’ is another harsh generalization. A thug is a violent person, and while the Black Panthers definitely practiced violence and had a do whatever it takes attitude, they never engaged in open warfare with the police unless they felt the need to do so. They did practice propaganda, but the propaganda they preached wasn’t one of hate, they only wanted to spread peace and equality. Even if through getting that peace and equality a bit of blood had to be spilled.
Looking at the different ways that the Black Panthers have been talked about and how their legacy still lives on through sports stars and pop culture. Its easy to see they were a very influential group and faction. The fact that we still talk about them today by way of what has recently happened with the cop shootings and sport stars such a Colin Kaepernick creating a youth group inspired by the Black Panthers, its hard to say that they weren’t just a violent group of people that were only proud of their race.

 Citations
1. "Colin Kaepernick Just Started A Black Panther-Inspired ..." N.p., n.d. Web. 11 Nov. 2016.
2. Wfld. "Milwaukee County Sheriff David Clarke Sounds off on Beyonce." WFLD. N.p., n.d. Web. 11 Nov. 2016.

3. David Oppenheimer, 2016, University of California Press





QUESTIONS!!!
1. The Black Panthers have a long history, what is one way to maybe make the historical context flow better?

2. What would you guys like to learn more about regarding the group?

3. What general tips do you have in regards to giving the paper a better flow.

P.S. - I am fairly sure that all the in paper citation are wrong, I am working on that as this is typed.

No comments:

Post a Comment