A shared workspace for ENGL306 at the University of Arizona
Sunday, September 18, 2016
Citizen: Initial Impression
I will preface my initial reaction to Citizen with an understanding that my
knowledge on the subject of the Black Lives Matter campaign has been tainted by
media coverage and social media exposure.
That being said, my impression of Citizen
as a work of protest was that of general confusion. Perhaps the culmination of many genres was
simply overwhelming to me because Claudia Rankine is obviously an esteemed poet
and writer, but I found myself lost mid-poem; I caught the idea/topic/scenario
but got confused among the syntax that I had to read some sections multiple
times to no avail. She clearly knows the content and her writing has been
clearly recognized as effective.
However, I was expecting more clarity.
I was anticipating arguments prefaced by precise titles and associated
with related works of art that were explained with relevance to the
protest. Instead, I read what seemed
like a long artistic script that ought to have been accompanied by an
inspirational video. I realize now that
the vague “chapters” may incline the reader to follow up search to learn the
background of the issue in particular.
The poetic pieces that I could comprehend whose subject I understood
were enjoyable. I figured that the poem on page 112-113 is likely in reference
to the unnecessary controversy surrounding President Obama as a citizen.
Although I recognized the context of the poem regarding the head-butting issue that
happened at the World Cup, I had a very difficult time dissecting the
connection to Rankine’s protest. I feel
that the book makes the assumption that the audience knows the context and both
appreciates and understands a very particular type of poetry. I am curious as to who Rankine made this book
for and who is accepting this as viable protest? The book portrays a sense of
struggle paired with collective identity surrounding that idea, but I was not
left with an impression to stand up to support the cause. Protest is about urging change, but not
always nor necessarily at the level of picking up a sign and shouting on the
street corner; perhaps Rankine’s protest goal is simply to get her readers to
consider their own role in racism.
Labels:
danieltannen,
Discussions
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment